The lobbyists who are pushing for a legislative perperiod program, price-fixing remedy conveniently ignore the fact that a per-program license was never originally conceived of as being proportional to a blanket license. They also perpetuate misinformation about the nature of the blanket license, which has traditionally produced license fees that reflect average music use of the entire industry. Thus, a station's blanket license fee was never conceived of as a ceiling price for other purposes. By using analogies which were never appropriate for pricing intangible property rights, the proponents of music licensing legislation have deceived decision-makers about the nature of the issues involved. In looking at pricing alternatives for creative property, we should be asking: How do we preserve the financial incentives that reward music creativity? What is the most expeditious way to provide music users with access to larger and ever-changing repertoires of music? How can we insure a modicum of fair payment to music property owners yet reflect sensitivity to the music users whose programming needs are quite diverse? Unfortunately, the proponents of this legislation are supported by special interest lobbyists who are trying to further develop their own businesses by legislatively undermining the intellectual and property rights granted to publishers and songwriters. It is sad to see that the method of their attack is to sow confusion throughout this Congress aspects inherent to intellectual about the property. commercial Please do not be deceived ... this legislation is a serious threat to the copyright laws that have been tested for many years. CONCLUSION Madam Chair, as a group of businesses which are wedded to the success of smaller businesses the writers of religious music - - we urge you to recognize the extraordinary genius of the music copyright system, and act to protect it from those groups who are attacking it for the prospect of their own financial gain. If the critics of the current licensing system succeed, the result will surely create instability within the music industry, particularly for religious publishers such as ourselves, but it also may make our society spiritually poorer in the end. PETITION FOR THE ABOLISHMENT OF ASCAP/ BMI We, the undersigned, request that American Society of Composers and Publishers (ASCAP) and Broadcast Music Inc. (BMI) be abolished from operating and collecting money in the state of Minnesota. We feel that these organizations are not fair or ethical in their methods and that the moneys collected are not reasonable or just. We object to the representatives' of ASCAP and BMI for these reasons: 1. Harassment. 2. Unreasonably high fees causing business shutdown. 3. Failure to properly identify themselves upon request. 4. Late night phone calls. 5. Stopping of community events where music is involved. 6. Intimidating behavior. 7. Frightening appearance. 8. "Tough" attitude. Because we feel that the musicians, the business owners and the general body of entertainers are not served by these organization we ask that they be voted out of Minnesota and a full investigation be made by appropriate government departments. Thank you. Partial list of signers- business only: VETERANS OF FOREIGN WARS GILMORE WEIK POST 5252 P.O. BOX Q PELICAN RAPIDS, MN 56572 SILVER DOLLAR BAR & GRILL ELIZABETH, MN. 56533 KRAEMER'S SUPPER CLUB EVANSVILLE, MN. 56326 OLD BRICK INN BATTLE LAKE, MN. 56515 MILLS LIQUORS NEW YORK MILLS, MN. 56567 V.F.W. POST 3289 NEW YORK MILLS, MN. 56567 V.F.W. 4020 PERHAM, MN. 56573 FRAZEE MUNICIPAL V.F.W. 3922 WADENA MN. 56482 ELKS WADENA, MN. 56482 V.F.W. POST 5252 PELICAN RAPIDS, MN. 56572 V.F.W. POST 1676 BARNSVILLE, MN. 56514 VAGT'S BARN RT. 1, BOX 158 BRECKENRIDGE, MN. 56520 CASEY'S BAR 202 MINN. AVE. BRECKENRIDGE, MN.56521 SONJU & ASSOCIATES AUCTIONEERS ALEXANDRIA, MN. 56308 INSULITE INSOLATION FERGUS FALLS, MN. 56537 GRAYSTONE LODGE BATTLE LAKE, MN. 56515 RIVER FRONT UNDERWOOD, MN. 56586 We, the undersigned, request that American Society of Composers and Publishers (ASCAP) and Broadcast Music Inc. (BMI) be abolished from operating and collecting money in the state of Minnesota. We feel that these organizations are not fair or ethical in their methods and that the moneys collected are not reasonable or just. We object to the representatives' of ASCAP and BIM for these reasons: Because we feel that the musicians, 'he business owners and the general body of entertainers are not served by these organization we ask that they be voted out of Minnesota and a full investigation be made, by appropriate government departments. Thank you. Balth Harthin Berze Worthen Qew French |