TABLE OF OVERRULED AND MODIFIED CASES1 Volume 1 to 78, inclusive [Cases marked with star (*) are now authority.] Administrative Ruling (43 L.D. 293); | Arundell, Thomas F. (33 L.D. 76); modified, 48 L.D. 98. Administrative Ruling (46 L.D. 32); vacated, 51 L.D. 287. Administrative Ruling (52 L.D. 359); distinguished, 59 I.D. 4, 5. Administrative Ruling, March 13, 1935; overruled, 58 I.D. 65, 81 (See 59 I.D. 69, 76). Alaska Commercial Company (39 L.D. 597); vacated, 41 L.D. 75. Alaska Copper Company (32 L.D. 128); overruled in part, 37 L.D. 674; 42 L.D. 255. Alaska-Dano Mines Co. (52 L.D. 550); overruled so far as in confict, 57 I.D. 244. Aldrich v. Anderson (2 L.D. 71); over ruled, 15 L.D. 201. Alheit, Rosa (40 L.D. 145); overruled so far as in conflict, 43 L.D. 342. Allen, Henry J. (37 L.D. 596); modified, 54 I.D. 4. Allen, Sarah E. (40 L.D. 586); modified, 44 L.D. 331. Americus v. Hall (29 L.D. 677); va cated, 30 L.D. 388. *Amidon v. Hegdale (39 L.D. 131); overruled, 40 L.D. 259 (See 42 L.D. 557). *Anderson, Andrew et al. (1 L.D. 1); overruled, 34 L.D. 606 (See 36 L.D. 14). Anderson v. Tannehill et al. (10 L.D. 388); overruled, 18 L.D. 586. Armstrong v. Matthews (40 L.D. 496); overruled so far as in conflict, 44| L.D. 156. overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 51. Ashton, Fred W. (31 L.D. 356); overruled, 42 L.D. 215. Atlantic and Pacific R.R. Co. (5 L.D. 269); overruled, 27 L.D. 241. *Auerbach, Samuel H. et al. (29 L.D. 208); overruled, 36 L.D. 36 (See 37 L.D. 715). Baca Float No. 3 (5 L.D. 705; 12 L.D. 676; 13 L.D. 624); vacated so far as in conflict, 29 L.D. 44. Bailey, John W. et al. (3 L.D. 386); modified, 5 L.D. 513. *Baker v. Hurst (7 L.D. 457); over ruled, 8 L.D. 110 (See 9 L.D. 360). Barbour v. Wilson et al. (23 L.D. 462); vacated, 28 L.D. 62. Barbut, James (9 L.D. 514); overruled so far as in conflict, 29 L.D. 698. Barlow, S. L. M. (5 L.D. 695); contra, 6 L.D. 648. Barnhurst v. State of Utah (30 L.D. 314); modified, 47 L.D. 359. Bartch v. Kennedy (3 L.D. 437); overruled, 6 L.D. 217. Beery v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co. et al. (41 L.D. 121); overruled, 43 L.D. 536. Bennet, Peter W. (6 L.D. 672); overruled, 29 L.D. 565. Bernardini, Eugene J. et al. (62 I.D. 231); distinguished, 63 I.D. 102. Big Lark (48 L.D. 479); distinguished, 58 I.D. 680, 682. Birkholz, John (27 L.D. 59) ; overruled so far as in conflict, 43 L.D. 221. Arnold v. Burger (45 L.D. 453); modi- Birkland, Bertha M. (45 L.D. 104); fied, 46 L.D. 320. overruled, 46 L.D. 110. 1 For abbreviations used in this title, see Editor's note at foot of page LXV. LI Bivins v. Shelly (2 L.D. 282); modified, | Burkholder v. Skagen (4 L.D. 166); 4 L.D. 583. *Black, L. C. (3 L.D. 101); overruled, 34 L.D. 606 (See 36 L.D. 14). Blenkner v. Sloggy (2 L.D. 267); over ruled, 6 L.D. 217. Boeschem, Conrad William (41 L.D. 309); vacated, 42 L.D. 244. Bosch, Gottlieb (8 L.D. 45); overruled, 13 L.D. 42. Box v. Ulstein (3 L.D. 143); overruled, 6 L.D. 217. Boyle, William (38 L.D. 603); overruled so far as in conflict, 44 L.D. 331. Braasch, William C. and Christ C. Prange (48 L.D. 448); overruled so far as in conflict, 60 I.D. 417, 419. Bradford, J. L. (31 L.D. 132); overruled, 35 L.D. 399. Bradstreet et al v. Rehm (21 L.D. 30); reversed, 21 L.D. 544. Brady v. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. (5 L.D. 407 and 658); overruled, 20 L.D. 259. Brandt, William W. (31 L.D. 277); overruled, 50 L.D. 161. Braucht et al. v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co. et al. (43 L.D. 536); modified, 44 L.D. 225. Brayton, Homer E. (31 L.D. 364); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 305. overruled, 9 L.D. 153. Burnham Chemical Co. v. United States Borax Co. et al. (54 I.D. 183); overruled in substance, 58 I.D. 426, 429. Burns, Frank (10 L.D. 365); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 454. Burns v. Vergh's Heirs (37 L.D. 161); vacated, 51 L.D. 268. Buttery v. Sprout (2 L.D. 293); overruled, 5 L.D. 591. Cagle v. Mendenhall (20 L.D. 447); overruled, 23 L.D. 533. Cain et al. v. Addenda Mining Co. (24 L.D. 18); vacated, 29 L.D. 62. California and Oregon Land Co. (21 L.D. 344); overruled, 26 L.D. 453. California, State of (14 L.D. 253); vacated, 23 L.D. 230. California, State of (15 L.D. 10); overruled, 23 L.D. 423. California, State of (19 L.D. 585); vacated, 28 L.D. 57. California, State of (22 L.D. 428); overruled, 32 L.D. 34. *California, State of (32 L.D. 346); vacated, 50 L.D. 628 (See 37 L.D. 499 and 46 L.D. 396). California, State of (44 L.D. 118); overruled, 48 L.D. 98. California, State of (44 L.D. 468); overruled, 48 L.D. 98. L.D. 359); overruled, 31 L.D. 335. California, State of v. Pierce (9 C.L.O. 118); modified, 2 L.D. 854. California, State of v. Smith (5 L.D. 543); overruled, 18 L.D. 343. Brick Pomeroy Mill Site (34 L.D. 320); California, State of v. Moccettini (19 overruled, 37 L.D. 674. Brown v. Cagle (30 L.D. 8); vacated, 30 L.D. 148 (See 47 L.D. 406). *Brown, Joseph T. (21 L.D. 47); overruled so far as in conflict, 31 L.D. 222 (See 35 L.D. 399). Browning, John W. (42 L.D. 1); overruled so far as in conflict, 43 L.D. 342. Bruns, Henry A. (15 L.D. 170); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 454. Bundy v. Livingston (1 L.D. 152); overruled, 6 L.D. 284. Call v. Swain (3 L.D. 46); overruled, 18 L.D. 373. Cameron Lode (13 L.D. 369); overruled so far as in conflict, 25 L.D. 518. Camplan v. Northern Pacific R.R. Co. (28 L.D. 118); overruled so far as in conflict, 29 L.D. 550. Burdick, Charles W. (34 L.D. 345); Case v. Church (17 L.D. 578); over modified, 42 L.D. 472. Burgess, Allen L. (24 L.D. 11); overruled so far as in conflict, 42 L.D. 321. ruled, 26 L.D. 453. Case v. Kuperschmidt (30 L.D. 9); overruled so far as in conflict, 47 L.D. 406. Castello v. Bonnie (20 L.D. 311); over- | Coffin, Mary E. (34 L.D. 564); overruled, 22 L.D. 174. Cate v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co. (41 L.D. 316); overruled so far as in conflict, 43 L.D. 60. Cawood v. Dumas (22 L.D. 585); va cated, 25 L.D. 526. Centerville Mining and Milling Co. (39 L.D. 80); no longer controlling, 48 L.D. 17. Central Pacific R.R. Co. (29 L.D. 589); modified, 48 L.D. 58. Central Pacific R.R. Co. v. Orr (2 L.D. ruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 51. Colorado, State of (7 L.D. 490); overruled, 9 L.D. 408. Condict, W. C. et al. (A-23366) June 24, 1942, unreported; overruled so far as in conflict, 59 I.D. 258-260. Cook, Thomas C. (10 L.D. 324) (See 39 L.D. 162, 225). Cooke v. Villa (17 L.D. 210); vacated, 19 L.D. 442. Cooper, John W. (15 L.D. 285); overruled, 25 L.D. 113. Copper Bullion and Morning Star Lode Mining Claims (35 L.D. 27) (See 39 L.D. 574). Copper Glance Lode (29 L.D. 542); overruled so far as in conflict, 55 I.D. 348. (13 L.D. 61); overruled, 20 L.D. 259. Chappell v. Clark (27 L.D. 334); modified, 27 L.D. 532. Chicago Placer Mining Claim (34 L.D. Corlis v. Northern Pacific R.R. Co. (23 9); overruled, 42 L.D. 543. L.D. 265); vacated, 26 L.D. 652. Childress et al. v. Smith (15 L.D. 89); Cornell v. Chilton (1 L.D. 153); over overruled, 26 L.D. 453. Chittenden, Frank O., and Interstate Oil Corp. (50 L.D. 262); overruled so far as in conflict, 53 I.D. 228. Christofferson, Peter (3 L.D. 329); modified, 6 L.D. 284, 624. Clafin v. Thompson (28 L.D. 279); overruled, 29 L.D. 693. Claney v. Ragland (38 L.D. 550) (See 43 L.D. 485). Clark, Yulu S. et al. (A-22852) February 20, 1941, unreported; overruled so far as in conflict, 59 I.D. 258, 260. Clarke, C. W. (32 L.D. 233); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 51. Clayton, Phebus (48 L.D. 128) (1921); overruled to extent inconsistent, 70 I.D. 159. Cline v. Urban (29 L.D. 96); overruled, 46 L.D. 492. Clipper Mining Co. (22 L.D. 527); no longer followed in part, 67 I.D. 417. Clipper Mining Co. v. The Eli Mining and Land Co. et al. (33 L.D. 660); no longer followed in part, 67 I.D. 417. Cochran v. Dwyer (9 L.D. 478) (See 39 L.D. 162, 225). Coffin, Edgar A. (33 L.D. 245); overruled so far as in conflict, 52 L.D. 153. ruled, 6 L.D. 483. Cowles v. Huff (24 L.D. 81); modified, 28 L.D. 515. Cox, Allen H. (30 L.D. 90, 468); vacated, 31 L.D. 114. Crowston v. Seal (5 L.D. 213); overruled, 18 L.D. 586. Culligan v. State of Minnesota (34 L.D. 22); modified, 34 L.D. 151. Cunningham, John (32 L.D. 207); modified, 32 L.D. 456. Dailey Clay Products Co., The (48 L.D. 429, 431); overruled so far as in conflict, 50 L.D. 656. Dakota Central R.R. Co. v. Downey (8 L.D. 115); modified, 20 L.D. 131. Davis, Heirs of (40 L.D. 573); overruled, 46 L.D. 110. DeLong v. Clarke (41 L.D. 278); modified so far as in confiict, 45 L.D. 54. Dempsey, Charles H. (42 L.D. 215); modified, 43 L.D. 300. Denison and Willits (11 C.L.O. 261); overruled so far as in conflict, 26 L.D. 122. Deseret Irrigation Co. et al. v. Sevier River Land and Water Co. (40 L.D. 463); overruled, 51 L.D. 27. Devoe, Lizzie A. (5 L.D. 4); modified, Febes, James H. (37 L.D. 210); over5 L.D. 429. ruled, 43 L.D. 183. Dickey, Ella I. (22 L.D. 351); over- Federal Shale Oil Co. (53 I.D. 213); overruled so far as in conflict, 55 I.D. 290. ruled, 32 L.D. 331. Dierks, Herbert (36 L.D. 367); over- 556); modified, 43 L.D. 128. Dowman v. Moss (19 L.D. 526); over ruled, 25 L.D. 82. Dudymott v. Kansas Pacific R.R. Co. (5 C.L.O. 69); overruled so far as in conflict, 1 L.D. 345. Dumphy, Elijah M. (8 L.D. 102); overruled so far as in conflict, 36 L.D. 561. Ferrell et al. v. Hoge et al. (18 L.D. Field, William C. (1 L.D. 68); over- Filtrol Company v. Brittan and Echart Fish, Mary (10 L.D. 606); modified, 13 Fisher v. Heirs of Rule (42 L.D. 62, Dyche v. Beleele (24 L.D. 494); modi- Fitch v. Sioux City and Pacific R.R. fied, 43 L.D. 56. Dysart, Francis J. (23 L.D. 282); modified, 25 L.D. 188. Co. (216 L. and R. 184); overruled, 17 L.D. 43. Fleming v. Bowe (13 L.D. 78); overruled, 23 L.D. 175. Easton, Francis E. (27 L.D. 600); over- Florida Mesa Ditch Co. (14 L.D. 265); ruled, 30 L.D. 355. East Tintic Consolidated Mining Co. (41 L.D. 255); vacated, 43 L.D. 80. *Elliot v. Ryan (7 L.D. 322); over ruled, 8 L.D. 110 (See 9 L.D. 360). El Paso Brick Co. (37 L.D. 155); overruled so far as in confiict, 40 L.D. 199. Elson, William C. (6 L.D. 797); overruled, 37 L.D. 330. overruled, 27 L.D. 421. Florida Railway and Navigation Co. v. Miller (3 L.D. 324); modified, 6 L.D. 716; overruled, 9 L.D. 237. Florida, State of (17 L.D. 355); reversed, 19 L.D. 76. Florida, State of (47 L.D. 92, 93); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 291. Emblem v. Reed (16 L.D. 28); modi- Forgeot, Margaret (7 L.D. 280); overfied, 17 L.D. 220. ruled, 10 L.D. 629. Epley v. Trick (8 L.D. 110); overruled, Fort Boise Hay Reservation (6 L.D. 9 L.D. 360. Erhardt, Finsans (36 L.D. 154); overruled, 38 L.D. 406. Esping v. Johnson (37 L.D. 709); overruled, 41 L.D. 289. Ewing v. Rickard (1 L.D. 146); overruled, 6 L.D. 483. Falconer v. Price (19 L.D. 167); over ruled, 24 L.D. 264. Fargo No. 2 Lode Claims (37 L.D. 404); modified, 43 L.D. 128: overruled so far as in conflict, 55 I.D. 348. Farrill, John W. (13 L.D. 713); overruled so far as in conflict, 52 L.D. 473. 16); overruled, 27 L.D. 505. Franco-Western Oil Company et al. (Supp.), 65 I.D. 427, is adhered to, 66 I.D. 362. Freeman, Flossie (40 L.D. 106); overruled, 41 L.D. 63. Freeman v. Texas and Pacific Ry. Co. (2 L.D. 550); overruled, 7 L.D. 18. Fry, Silas A. (45 L.D. 20); modified, 51 L.D. 581. Fults, Bill, 61 I.D. 437 (1954); overruled, 69 I.D. 181. Galliher, Maria (8 C.L.O. 137); overruled, 1 L.D. 57. Gallup v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co. (un- | Gwyn, James R. (A-26806) December published); overruled so far as in 17, 1953, unreported; distinguished, conflict, 47 L.D. 304. 66 I.D. 275. Gariss v. Borin (21 L.D. 542) (See 39 L.D. 162, 225). Garrett, Joshua (7 C.L.O. 55); overruled, 5 L.D. 158. Hagood, L. N., et al., 65 I.D. 405 (1958); overruled, Beard Oil Company, 1, IBLA 42, 77 I.D. 166 (1970). Garvey v. Tuiska (41 L.D. 510); modi- Halvorson, Halvor K. (39 L.D. 456); fied, 43 L.D. 229. Gates v. California and Oregon R.R. Co. (5 C.L.O. 150); overruled, 1 L.D. 336. Gauger, Henry (10 L.D. 221); over ruled, 24 L.D. 81. Glassford, A. W. et al. 56 I.D. 88 (1937); overruled to extent inconsistent, 70 I.D. 159. Gleason v. Pent (14 L.D. 375; 15 L.D. 286); vacated, 53 I.D. 447; overruled so far as in conflict, 59 I.D. 416, 422. Gohrman v. Ford (8 C.L.O. 6); overruled so far as in conflict, 4 L.D. 580. Golden Chief "A" Placer Claim (35 L.D. 557); modified, 37 L.D. 250. Goldstein v. Juneau Townsite (23 L.D. 417); vacated, 31 L.D. 88. overruled, 41 L.D. 505. Hansbrough, Henry C. (5 L.D. 155); Hardee, D. C. (7 L.D. 1); overruled so Hardin, James A. (10 L.D. 313); re- Harris, James G. (28 L.D. 90); over- Harrison, Luther (4 L.D. 179); over- Hart v. Cox (42 L.D. 592); vacated, Goodale v. Olney (12 L.D. 324); dis- Hastings and Dakota Ry. Co. v. Christtinguished, 55 I.D. 580. Gotebo Townsite v. Jones (35 L.D. 18); modified, 37 L.D. 560. Gowdy v. Connell (27 L.D. 56); vacated, 28 L.D. 240. Gowdy v. Gilbert (19 L.D. 17); over ruled, 26 L.D. 453. Gowdy et al. v. Kismet Gold Mining enson et al. (22 L.D. 257); overruled, 28 L.D. 572. Hausman, Peter A. C. (37 L.D. 352); modified, 48 L.D. 629. Hayden v. Jamison (24 L.D. 403); vacated, 26 L.D. 373. Haynes v. Smith (50 L.D. 208); overruled so far as in conflict, 54 I.D. 150. Co. (22 L.D. 624); modified, 24 L.D. | Heilman v. Syverson (15 L.D. 184); 191. Grampian Lode (1 L.D. 544); over- Gregg et al. v. State of Colorado (15 (22 L.D. 438); vacated, 23 L.D. 489. *Ground Hog Lode v. Parole and Morning Star Lodes (8 L.D. 430); overruled, 34 L.D. 568 (See R. R. Rousseau, 47 L.D. 590). Guidney, Alcide (8 C.L.O. 157); overruled, 40 L.D. 399. overruled, 23 L.D. 119. Heinzman et al. v. Letroadec's Heirs et al. (28 L.D. 497); overruled, 38 L.D. 253. Heirs of Davis (40 L.D. 573); over- Heirs of Mulnix, Philip (33 L.D. 331) ; Gulf and Ship Island RR. Co. (16 L.D. Heirs of Vradenberg et al. v. Orr et al. 236); modified, 19 L.D. 534. (25 L.D. 232); overruled, 38 L.D. 253. Gustafson, Olof (45 L.D. 456); modi- Helmer, Inkerman (34 L.D. 341); modi fied, 46 L.D. 442. fied, 42 L.D. 472. |