CUMULATIVE INDEX TO SUITS FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW OF DEPARTMENTAL DECISIONS PUBLISHED IN INTERIOR DECISIONS

The table below sets out in alphabetical order, arranged according to the last name of the first party named in the Department's decision, all the departmental decisions published in the Interior Decisions, beginning with volume 61, judicial review of which was sought by one of the parties concerned. The name of the action is listed as it appears on the court docket in each court. Where the decision of the court has been published, the citation is given; if not, the docket number and date of final action taken by the court is set out. If the court issued an opinion in a nonreported case, that fact is indicated; otherwise no opinion was written. Unless otherwise indicated, all suits were commenced in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia and, if appealed, were appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Finally, if judicial review resulted in a further departmental decision, the departmental decision is cited. Actions shown are those taken prior to the end of the year covered by this volume.

Adler Construction Co., 67 I.D. 21 (1960) (Reconsideration)

Alder Construction Co. v. U.S., Cong. 10-60. Dismissed, 423 F. 2d 1362 (1970); rehearing denied, July 15, 1970; cert. denied, 400 U.S. 993 (1970); rehearing denied, 401 U.S. 949 (1971).

Adler Construction Co. v. U.S., Cong. 5–70. Suit pending.

Estate of John J. Akers, 77 I.D. 268 (1970)

Dolly Custer Akers v. The Dept. of the Interior, Civil No. 907, D. Mont. Judgment for defendant, September 17, 1971; order staying execution of judgment for 30 days issued October 15, 1971.

State of Alaska

Andrew Kalerak, Jr., 73 I.D. 1 (1966)

Andrew J. Kalerak, Jr., et al. v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. A-35–66, D. Alas. Judgment for plaintiff, October 20, 1966; rev'd., 396 F. 2d 746 (9th Cir. 1968); cert. denied, 393 U.S. 1118 (1969).

Allied Contractors, Inc., 68 I.D. 145 (1961)

Allied Contractors, Inc. v. U.S., Ct. Cl. No. 163-63. Stipulation of settlement filed March 3, 1967; compromised.

Leslie N. Baker, et al., A-28454 (October 26, 1960). On reconsideration Autrice C. Copeland, 69 I.D. 1 (1962).

Autrice Copeland Freeman v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 1578, D. Ariz. judgment for defendant, September 3, 1963 (opinion); aff'd., 336 F. 2d 706 (9th Cir. 1964); no petition.

462-392-72- -2

XVII

Max Barash, The Texas Co., 63 I.D. 51 (1956)

Max Barash v. Douglas McKay, Civil No. 939–56. Judgment for defendant, June 13, 1957; rev'd. & remanded, 256 F. 2d 714 (1958); judgment for plaintiff, December 18, 1958. Supplemental decision, 66 I.D. 11 (1959); no petition. Barnard-Curtiss Co., 64 I.D. 312 (1957) 65 I.D. 49 (1958)

Barnard-Curtiss Co. v. U.S., Ct. Cl. No. 491-59. Judgment for plaintiff, 301 F.2d 909 (1962).

Eugenia Bate, 69 I.D. 230 (1962)

Katherine S. Foster & Brook H. Duncan, II v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 5258, D. N.M. Judgment for defendant, January 8, 1964; rev'd., 335 F. 2d 828 (10th Cir. 1964); no petition.

Sam Bergesen, 62 I.D. 295

Reconsideration denied, IBCA-11 (December 19, 1955)

Sam Bergesen v. U.S., Civil No. 2044, D. Wash. Complaint dismissed March 11, 1958; no appeal.

BLM-A-045569, 70 I.D. 231 (1963)

New York State Natural Gas Corp. v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 2109-63. Consolidated Gas Supply Corp. v. Stewart L. Udall, et al., Civil No. 2109– 63. Judgment for defendant, September 20, 1965; Per curiam decision, aff'd., April 28, 1966; no petition.

Lloyd W. Booth, 76 I.D. 73 (1969)

Lloyd W. Booth v. Walter J. Hickel, Civil No. 42-69, D. Alas. Judgment for defendant, June 30, 1970; no appeal.

Melvin A. Brown, 69 I.D. 131 (1962)

Melvin A. Brown v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 3352-62. Judgment for defendant, September 17, 1963; rev'd., 335 F. 2d 706 (1964); no petition.

R. C. Buch, 75 I.D. 140 (1968)

R. C. Buch v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 68–1358-PH, C.D. Cal. Judgment for plaintiff, 298 F. Supp. 381 (1969); rev'd., August 31, 1971; rehearing denied, September 29, 1971.

The California Co., 66 I.D. 54 (1959)

The California Co. v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 980-59. Judgment for defendant, 187 F. Supp. 445 (1960); aff'd., 296 F. 2d 384 (1961).

In the Matter of Cameron Parish, Louisiana, Cameron Parish Police Jury & Cameron Parish School Board, June 3, 1968 appealed by Secretary July 5, 1968, 75 I.D. 289 (1968).

Cameron Parish Police Jury v. Stewart L. Udall, et al., Civil No. 14,206, W.D. La. Judgment for plaintiff, 302 F. Supp. 689 (1969); order vacating prior order issued November 5, 1969.

Carson Construction Co., 62 I.D. 422 (1955)

Carson Construction Co. v. U.S., Ct. Cl. No. 487-59. Judgment for plaintiff, December 14, 1961; no appeal.

Chargeability of Acreage Embraced in Oil and Gas Lease Offers, 71 I.D. 337 (1964), Shell Oil Co., A-30575 (October 31, 1966)

Shell Oil Co. v. Udall, Civil No. 216-67. Stipulation of dismissal filed August 19, 1968.

Chemi-Cote Perlite Corp. v. Arthur C. W. Bowen, 72 I.D. 403 (1965)

Bowen v. Chemi-Cote Perlite, No. 2 CA-Civ. 248, Ariz. Ct. App. Decision against the Dept. by the lower court aff'd., 423 P. 2d 104 (1967); rev'd., 432 P.2d 435 (1967).

Stephen H. Clarkson, 72 I.D. 138 (1965)

Stephen H. Clarkson v. U.S., Cong. Ref. 5–68. Trial Commr's. report adverse to U.S. issued December 16, 1970; Chief Commr's. report concurring with the Trial Commr's. report issued April 13, 1971.

Mrs. Hannah Cohen, 70 I.D. 188 (1963)

Hannah and Abram Cohen v. U.S., Civil No. 3158, D. R. I. Compromised. Barney R. Colson, 70 I.D. 409 (1963)

Barney R. Colson, et al. v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 63-26-Civ.-Oc. M.D. Fla. Dismissed with prejudice, 278 F. Supp. 826 (1968); aff'd., 428 F.2d 1046 (5th Cir. 1970); cert. denied, 401 U.S. 911 (1971).

Columbian Carbon Co., Merwin E. Liss, 63 I.D. 166 (1956)

Merwin E. Liss v. Fred A. Seaton, Civil No. 3233–56. Judgment for defendant, January 9, 1958; appeal dismissed for want of prosecution, September 18, 1958, D.C. Cir. No. 14,647.

Appeal by the Confederated Salish & Kootenai Tribes of the Flathead Reservation, in the Matter of the Enrollment of Mrs. Elverna Y. Clairmont Baciarelli, 77 I.D. 116 (1970)

Elverna Yevonne Clairmont Baciarelli v. Walter J. Hickel, Civil No. C-702200, D. Cal. Judgment for defendant, August 27, 1971; appeal docketed October 22, 1971.

Appeal of Continental Oil Co., 68 I.D. 337 (1961)

Continental Oil Co. v. Stewart L. Udall, et al., Civil No. 366-62. Judgment for defendant, April 29, 1966; aff'd., February 10, 1967; cert. denied, 389 U.S. 839 (1967).

Autrice C. Copeland

See Leslie N. Baker et al.

Appeal of Cosmo Construction Co., 73 I.D. 229 (1966)

Cosmo Construction Co., et al. v. U.S., Ct. Cl. 119–68, Ct. opinion setting case for trial on the merits issued March 19, 1971.

John C. de Armas, Jr., P. A. McKenna, 63 I.D. 82 (1956)

Patrick A. McKenna v. Clarence A. Davis, Civil No. 2125-56. Judgment for defendant, June 20, 1957; aff'd., 259 F. 2d 780 (1958); cert denied, 358 U.S. 385 (1958).

The Dredge Corp., 64 I.D. 368 (1957), 65 I.D. 336 (1958)

The Dredge Corp. v. J. Russell Penny, Civil No. 475, D. Nev. Judgment for defendant, September 9, 1964; aff'd., 362 F. 2d 889 (9th Cir. 1966); no petition. See also Dredge Co. v. Husite Co., 369 P. 2d 676 (1962); cert. denied, 371 U.S. 821 (1962).

John J. Farrelly, et al., 62 I.D.1 (1955)

John J. Farrelly & The Fifty-One Oil Co., v. Douglas McKay, Civil No. 3037– 55. Judgment for plaintiff, October 11, 1955; no appeal.

T. Jack Foster, 75 I.D. 81 (1968)

Gladys H. Foster, Executrix of the estate of T. Jack Foster v. Stewart L. Udall, Boyd L. Rasmussen, Civil No. 7611. D. N.M. Judgment for plaintiff, June 2, 1969; no appeal.

Franco Western Oil Co., et al., 65 I.D. 316, 427 (1958)

Raymond J. Hansen v. Fred A. Seaton, Civil No. 2810-59. Judgment for plaintiff, August 2, 1960 (opinion); no appeal.

See Safarik v. Udall, 304 F. 2d 944 (1962); cert. denied, 371 U.S. 901 (1962).

Gabbs Exploration Co., 67 I.D. 160 (1960)

Gabbs Exploration Co. v Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 219-61. Judgment for defendant, December 1, 1961; aff'd., 315 F. 2d 37 (1963); cert. denied, 375 U.S. 822 (1963).

Stanley Garthofner, Duvall Bros., 67 I.D. 4 (1960)

Stanley Garthofner v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 4194-60. Judgment for plaintiff, November 27, 1961; no appeal.

General Excavating Co., 67 I.D. 344 (1960)

General Excavating Co. v. U.S., Ct. Cl. No. 170-62. Dismissed with prejudice December 16, 1963.

Nelson A. Gerttula, 64 I.D. 225 (1957)

Nelson A. Gerttula v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 685–60. Judgment for defendant, June 20, 1961; motion for rehearing denied, August 3, 1961; aff'd., 309 F.2d 653 (1962); no petition.

Charles B. Gonsales et al., Western Oil Fields, Inc., et al., 69 I.D. 236 (1962)

Pan American Petroleum Corp. & Charles B. Gonsales v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil No. 5246, D. N.M. Judgment for defendant, June 4, 1964; aff'd., 352 F.2d 32 (10th Cir. 1965); no petition.