1 TABLE OF OVERRULED AND MODIFIED CASES 1 Volumes 1 to 66, inclusive [Cases marked with star (*) are now authority.] Administrative Ruling (43 L.D. 293); | Ashton, Fred W. (31 L.D. 356); overmodified, 48 L.D. 98. ruled, 42 L.D. 215. Administrative Ruling (46 L.D. 32); Atlantic and Pacific R.R. Co. (5 L.D. vacated, 51 L.D. 287. 269); overruled, 27 L.D. 241. Administrative Ruling (52 L.D. 359); | *Auerbach, Samuel H., et al. (29 L.D. distinguished, 59 I.D. 4, 5. 208); overruled, 36 L.D. 36. (See 37 Baca Float No. 3 (5 L.D. 705; 12 L.D. 676; 13 L.D. 624); vacated so far as in conflict, 29 L.D. 44. Bailey, John W., et al. (3 L.D. 386); modified, 5 L.D. 513. *Baker v. Hurst (7 L.D. 457); overruled, 8 L.D. 110. (See 9 L.D. 360.) Barbour v. Wilson et al. (23 L.D. 462); vacated, 28 L.D. 62. Aldrich v. Anderson (2 L.D. 71); over- | Barbut, James (9 L.D. 514); overruled ruled, 15 L.D. 201. Alheit, Rosa (40 L.D. 145): overruled so far as in conflict, 43 L.D. 342. Allen, Henry J. (37 L.D. 596); modified, 54 I.D. 4. so far as in conflict, 29 L.D. 698. Barlow, S. L. M. (5 L.D. 695); contra, 6 L.D. 648. Barnhurst v. State of Utah (30 L.D. 314); modified, 47 L.D. 359. Allen, Sarah E. (40 L.D. 586); modi- Bartch v. Kennedy ( 3 L.D. 437); overfied, 44 L.D. 331. ruled, 6 L.D. 217. Americus v. Hall (29 L.D. 677); va- Beery v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co. et al. cated, 30 L.D. 388. *Amidon v. Hegdale (39 L.D. 131); overruled, 40 L.D. 259. (See 12 L.D. 557.) *Anderson, Andrew, et al. (1 L.D. 1); overruled, 34 L.D. 606. (See 36 L.D. 14.) (41 L.D. 121); overruled, 43 L.D. 536. Bennet, Peter W. (6 L.D. 672); overruled, 29 L.D. 565. Bernardini, Eugene J., et al. (62 I.D. so far as in conflict. 43 L.D. 221. Birkland, Bertha M. (45 L.D. 104); overruled, 46 L.D. 110. Anderson v. Tannehill et al. (10 L.D. Birkholz, John (27 L.D. 59); overruled 388); overruled, 18 L.D. 586. Appeal of Paul Jarvis, Inc., (64 I.D. 285); distinguished, 64 I.D. 388. Armstrong v. Matthews (40 L.D. 496) ; | overruled so far as in conflict, 44 L.D. 156. Arnold v. Burger (45 L.D. 453); modified, 46 L.D. 320. Arundell, Thomas F. (33 L.D. 76); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 51. Bivins v. Shelly (2 L.D. 282); modified, 4 L.D. 583. *Black, L. C. (3 L.D. 101); overruled, 34 L.D. 606. (See 36 L.D. 14.) Blenkner v. Sloggy (2 L.D. 267); overruled, 6 L.D. 217. Boeschem, Conrad William (41 L.D. 309); vacated, 42 L.D. 244. 1 For abbreviations used in this title, see Editor's note at foot of page XLIV. XXXI Bosch, Gottlieb (8 L.D. 45); overruled, | Burns v. Bergh's Heirs (37 L.D. 161); 13 L.D. 42. vacated, 51 L.D. 268. Box v. Ulstein (3 L.D. 143); over- Buttery v. Sprout (2 L.D. 293); overruled, 6 L.D. 217. Boyle, William (38 L.D. 603); overruled so far as in conflict, 44 L.D. 331. Braasch, William C., and Christ C. Prange (48 L.D. 448); overruled so far as in conflict, 60 I.D. 417, 419. Bradford, J. L. (31 L.D. 132); overruled, 35 L.D. 399. Bradstreet et al. v. Rehm (21 L.D. 30); reversed, 21 L.D. 544. Brady v. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. (5 L.D. 407 and 658); overruled, 20 L.D. 259. ruled, 5 L.D. 591. Cagle v. Mendenhall (20 L.D. 447); overruled, 23 L.D. 533. Cain et al. v. Addenda Mining Co. (24 L.D. 18); vacated, 29 L.D. 62. California and Oregon Land Co. (21 L.D. 344); overruled, 26 L.D. 453. California, State of (14 L.D. 253); vacated, 23 L.D. 230. California, State of (15 L.D. 10); overruled, 23 L.D. 423. California, State of (19 L.D. 585); vacated, 28 L.D. 57. Brandt, William W. (31 L.D. 277); California, State of (22 L.D. 428) ; overoverruled, 50 L.D. 161. Braucht et al. v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co. et al. (43 L.D. 536); modified, 44 L.D. 225. Brayton, Homer E. (31 L.D. 364); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 305. Brick Pomeroy Mill Site (34 L.D. 320); overruled, 37 L.D. 674. *Brown, Joseph T. (21 L.D. 47); overruled so far as in conflict, 31 L.D. 222. (See 35 L.D. 399.) Brown v. Cagle (30 L.D. 8); vacated, 30 L.D. 148. (See 47 L.D. 406.) Browning, John W. (42 L.D. 1); overruled so far as in conflict, 43 L.D. 342. Bruns, Henry A. (15 L.D. 170); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 454. Bundy v. Livingston (1 L.D. 152); overruled, 6 L.D. 284. Burdick, Charles W. (34 L.D. 345); modified, 42 L.D. 472. Burgess, Allen L. (24 L.D. 11); overruled so far as in conflict, 42 L.D. 321. ruled, 32 L.D. 34. California, State of (32 L.D. 346); vacated, 50 L.D. 628. (See 37 L.D. 499 and 46 L.D. 396.) California, State of (44 L.D. 118); overruled, 48 L.D. 98. California, State of (44 L.D. 468); overruled, 48 L.D. 98. California, State of v. Moccettini (19 L.D. 359); overruled, 31 L.D. 335. California, State of v. Pierce (9 C.L.O. 118); modified, 2 L.D. 854. California, State of v. Smith (5 L.D. 543); overruled, 18 L.D. 343. Call v. Swaim (3 L.D. 46); overruled, 18 L.D. 373. Cameron Lode (13 L.D. 369); overruled so far as in conflict, 25 L.D. 518. Camplan v. Northern Pacific R.R. Co. (28 L.D. 118); overruled so far as in conflict, 29 L.D. 550. Case v. Church (17 L.D. 578); overruled, 26 L.D. 453. Case v. Kupferschmidt (30 L.D. 9); overruled so far as in conflict, 47 L.D. 406. Burkholder v. Skagen (4 L.D. 166); Castello v. Bonnie (20 L.D. 311); over overruled, 9 L.D. 153. Burnham Chemical Co. v. United States Borax Co. et al. (54 I.D. 183); overruled in substance, 58 I.D. 426, 429. Burns, Frank (10 L.D. 365); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 454. ruled, 22 L.D. 174. Cate v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co. (41 L.D. 316); overruled so far as in conflict, 43 L.D. 60. Cawood v. Dumas (22 L.D. 585); vacated, 25 L.D. 526. Centerville Mining and Milling Co. (39 | Copper Bullion and Morning Star Lode Central Pacific R.R. Co. (29 L.D. 589); Copper Glance Lode (29 L.D. 542); modified, 48 L.D. 58. overruled so far as in conflict, 55 I.D. Corlis v. Northern Pacific R.R. Co. (23 Central Pacific R.R. Co. v. Orr (2 L.D. 525); overruled, 11 L.D. 445. Chapman v. Willamette Valley and Cascade Mountain Wagon Road Co. (13 L.D. 61); overruled, 20 L.D. 259. Chappell v. Clark (27 L.D. 334); modifred, 27 L.D. 532. Chicago Placer Mining Claim (34 L.D. | Cox, Allen H. (30 L.D. 90, 468); va9); overruled, 42 L.D. 453. cated, 31 L.D. 114. Cowles v. Huff (24 L.D. 81); modified, 28 L.D. 515. ruled, 18 L.D. 586. Childress et al. v. Smith (15 L.D. 89); Crowston v. Seal (5 L.D. 213); overoverruled, 26 L.D. 453. Chittenden, Frank O., and Interstate Oil Corp. (50 L.D. 262); overruled so far as in conflict, 53 I.D. 228. Christofferson, Peter (3 L.D. 329); modified, 6 L.D. 284, 624. Culligan v. State of Minnesota (34 L.D. 22); modified, 34 L.D. 151. Cunningham, John (32 L.D. 207); modified, 32 L.D. 456. Claflin v. Thompson (28 L.D. 279); Dailey Clay Products Co., The (48 L.D. Cochran v. Dwyer (9 L.D. 478). (See 39 L.D. 162, 225.) Coffin, Edgar A. (33 L.D. 245); overruled so far as in conflict, 52 L.D. 153. Coffin, Mary E. (34 L.D. 564); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 51. Colorado, State of (7 L.D. 490); overruled, 9 L.D. 408. Condict, W. C., et al. (A. 23366), June 24, 1942, unreported; overruled so far as in conflict, 59 L.D. 258-260. 429, 431); overruled so far as in con- Dakota Central R.R. Co. v. Downey (8 DeLong v. Clarke (41 L.D. 278); modi fied so far as in conflict, 45 L.D. 54. Dempsey, Charles H. (42 L.D. 215); modified, 43 L.D. 300. Denison and Willits (11 C.L.O. 261); Deseret Irrigation Co. et al. v. Sevier 5 L.D. 429. Dickey, Ella I. (22 L.D. 351); overruled, 32 L.D. 331. Dierks, Herbert (36 L.D. 367); over ruled by the unreported case of Thomas J. Guigham, March 11, 1909. Cook, Thomas C. (10 L.D. 324). (See Dixon v. Dry Gulch Irrigation Co. (45 39 L.D. 162, 225.) L.D. 4); overruled, 51 L.D. 27. Cooke v. Villa (17 L.D. 210); vacated, Douglas and Other Lodes (34 L.D. 19 L.D. 442. 556); modified, 43 L.D. 128. Cooper, John W. (15 L.D. 285); over- Dowman v. Moss (19 L.D. 526); overruled, 25 L.D. 113. ruled, 25 L.D. 82. 545659-60 Dudymott v. Kansas Pacific R.R. Co. | Field, William C. (1 L.D. 68); overruled so far as in conflict, 52 L.D. 473. (5 C.L.O. 69); overruled so far as in conflict, 1 L.D. 345. Dunphy, Elijah M. (8 L.D. 102); overruled so far as in conflict, 36 L.D. 561. Filtrol Company v. Brittan and Echart (51 L.D. 649); distinguished, 55 I.D. 605. Dyche v. Beleele (24 L.D. 494); modi- Fish, Mary (10 L.D. 606); modified, fied, 43 L.D. 56. 13 L.D. 511. Dysart, Francis J. (23 L.D. 282); modi- Fisher v. Heirs of Rule (42 L.D. 62, fied, 25 L.D. 188. Easton, Francis E. (27 L.D. 600); overruled, 30 L.D. 355. East Tintic Consolidated Mining Co. (41 L.D. 255); vacated, 43 L.D. 80. *Elliott v. Ryan (7 L.D. 322); overruled, 8 L.D. 110. (See 9 L.D. 360.) El Paso Brick Co. (37 L.D. 155); overruled so far as in conflict, 40 L.D. 199. 64); vacated, 43 L.D. 217. Fitch v. Sioux City and Pacific R.R. Co. (216 L. and R. 184); overruled, 17 L.D. 43. Fleming v. Bowe (13 L.D. 78); overruled, 23 L.D. 175. Florida, State of (17 L.D. 355); reversed, 19 L.D. 76. Florida, State of (47 L.D. 92, 93); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 291. Elson, William C. (6 L.D. 797); over- Florida Mesa Ditch Co. (14 L.D. 265); ruled, 37 L.D. 330. overruled, 27 L.D. 421. Emblem v. Weed (16 L.D. 28); modi- Florida Railway and Navigation Co. v. fied, 17 L.D. 220. Epley v. Trick (8 L.D. 110); overruled, 9 L.D. 360. Erhardt, Finsans (36 L.D. 154); overruled, 38 L.D. 406. Esping v. Johnson (37 L.D. 709); overruled, 41 L.D. 289. Ewing v. Rickard (1 L.D. 146); overruled, 6 L.D. 483. Falconer v. Price (19 L.D. 167); over ruled, 24 L.D. 264. Fargo No. 2 Lode Claims (37 L.D. 404); modified, 43 L.D. 128; overruled so far as in conflict, 55 I.D. 348. Farrill, John W. (13 L.D. 713); overruled so far as in conflict, 52 L.D. 473. Miller (3 L.D. 324); modified, 6 L.D. 716; overruled, 9 L.D. 237. Forgeot, Margaret (7 L.D. 280); overruled, 10 L.D. 629. Fort Boise Hay Reservation (6 L.D. 16); overruled, 27 L.D. 505. Freeman, Flossie (40 L.D. 106); overruled, 41 L.D. 63. Freeman v. Texas and Pacific Ry. Co. (2 L.D. 550); overruled, 7 L.D. 18. Fry, Silas A. (45 L.D. 20); modified, 51 L.D. 581, Galliher, Maria (8 C.L.O. 137); overruled, 1 L.D. 57. Gallup v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co. (unpublished); overruled so far as in conflict, 47 L.D. 304. Gariss v. Borin (21 L.D. 542). (See 39 L.D. 162, 225.) Febes, James H. (37 L.D. 210); over- Garrett, Joshua (7 C.L.O. 55); over ruled, 43 L.D. 183. Federal Shale Oil Co. (53 I.D. 213); overruled so far as in conflict, 55 I.D. 290. Ferrell et al. v. Hoge et al. (18 L.D. 781); overruled, 25 L.D. 351. ruled, 5 L.D. 158. Garvey v. Tuiska (41 L.D. 510); modified, 43 L.D. 229. Gates v. California and Oregon R.R. Co. (5 C.L.O. 150); overruled, 1 L.D. 336. Fette v. Christiansen (29 L.D. 710); Gauger, Henry (10 L.D. 221); overoverruled, 34 L.D. 167. ruled, 24 L.D. 81. Gleason v. Pent (14 L.D. 375; 15 L.D. | Hardin, James A. (10 L.D. 313); re 286); vacated, 53 I.D. 447; overruled so far as in conflict, 59 I.D. 416, 422. Gohrman v. Ford (8 C.L.O. 6); overruled so far as in conflict, 4 L.D. 580. Golden Chief "A" Placer Claim (35 L.D. 557); modified, 37 L.D. 250. Goldstein v. Juneau Townsite (23 L.D. 417); vacated, 31 L.D. 88. voked, 14 L.D. 233. Harris, James G. (28 L.D. 90); overruled, 39 L.D. 93. Harrison, Luther (4 L.D. 179); overruled, 17 L.D. 216. Harrison, W. R. (19 L.D. 299); overruled, 33 L.D. 539. Hart v. Cox (42 L.D. 592); vacated, 260 U.S. 427. (See 49 L.D. 413.) Goodale v. Olney (12 L.D. 324); dis- Hastings and Dakota Ry. Co. v. tinguished, 55 I.D. 580. Gotebo Townsite v. Jones (35 L.D. 18); modified, 37 L.D. 560. Gowdy v. Connell (27 L.D. 56); va cated, 28 L.D. 240. Gowdy v. Gilbert (19 L.D. 17); over ruled, 26 L.D. 453. Gowdy et al. v. Kismet Gold Mining Co. (22 L.D. 624); modified, 24 L.D. 191. Grampian Lode (1 L.D. 544); over ruled, 25 L.D. 495. Gregg et al. v. State of Colorado (15 L.D. 151); modified, 30 L.D. 310. Grinnell v. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. (22 L.D. 438); vacated, 23 L.D. 489. *Ground Hog Lode v. Parole and Morn ing Star Lodes (8 L.D. 430); overruled, 34 L.D. 568. (See R. R. Rousseau, 47 L.D. 590.) Guidney, Alcide (8 C.L.O. 157); overruled, 40 L.D. 399. Christenson et al. (22 L.D. 257); overruled, 28 L.D. 572. Hausman, Peter A. C. (37 L.D. 352); modified, 48 L.D. 629. Hayden v. Jamison (24 L.D. 403); vacated, 26 L.D. 373. Haynes v. Smith (50 L.D. 208); overruled so far as in conflict, 54 I.D. 150. Heilman v. Syverson (15 L.D. 184); overruled, 23 L.D. 119. Heinzman et al v. Letroadec's Heirs et al. (28 L.D. 497); overruled, 38 L.D. 253. Heirs of Davis (40 L.D. 573); overruled, 46 L.D. 110. Heirs of Philip Mulnix (33 L.D. 331); overruled, 43 L.D. 532. *Heirs of Stevenson v. Cunningham (32 L.D. 650); overruled so far as in conflict, 41 L.D. 119. (See 43 L.D. 196.) Heirs of Talkington v. Hempfling (2 L.D. 46); overruled, 14 L.D. 200. Gulf and Ship Island R.R. Co. (16 L.D. Heirs of Vradenberg et al. v. Orr et al. 236); modified, 19 L.D. 534. Gustafson, Olof (45 L.D. 456); modified, 46 L.D. 442. Gwyn, James R. (A. 26806), December 17, 1953, unreported; distinguished, 66 I.D. 275. (25 L.D. 232); overruled, 38 L.D. 253. Helmer, Inkerman (34 L.D. 341); modified, 42 L.D. 472. Helphrey v. Coil (49 L.D. 624); overruled, Dennis v. Jean (A-20899), July 24, 1937, unreported. Halvorson, Halvor K. (39 L.D. 456); | Henderson, John W. (40 L.D. 518); overruled, 41 L.D. 505. Hansbrough, Henry C. (5 L.D. 155); overruled, 29 L.D. 59. Hardee, D. C. (7 L.D. 1); overruled so far as in conflict, 29 L.D. 698. Hardee v. United States (8 L.D. 391; 16 L.D. 499); overruled so far as in conflict, 29 L.D. 689. 545659-60 -4 (See 44 L.D. vacated, 43 L.D. 106. 112, and 49 L.D. 484.) Hennig, Nellie J. (38 L.D. 443, 445); recalled and vacated, 39 L.D. 211. Hensel, Ohmer V. (45 L.D. 557); distinguished, 66 I.D. 275. Herman v. Chase et al. (37 L.D. 590); overruled, 43 L.D. 246. |